Elks Lodge is a association or organization in New Castle, IN. Phone: (765) 529-2402. Average rating is 4.7 stars from 60 reviews. Website: http://elks484.com/.
Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks emblemNew Castle, IN Elks Lodge #484
Call Now Directions
Review
Interior view of the Elks Lodge with patrons and holiday decorations.
4.7 60 reviews

New Castle's Favorite Lunch Stop Since Forever

Great food, unbeatable prices, and a welcoming crowd right on South Main Street.

Charity

Giving without expectation

Justice

Fairness for every person

Brotherly Love

Fellowship above all

Fidelity

Faithful to our word

About Us

Elks Lodge building with flags and a welcoming entrance.
Elks Lodge building with flags and a welcoming entrance.

Here's something most people in New Castle don't know: Elks Lodge 484 at 309 S Main St is open to the public for lunch on weekdays, and the regulars would rather keep it that way. No membership card required. Just walk in, sit down, and order a hot meal that costs less than you'd expect and tastes better than you'd hope.

The dining room draws a loyal crowd of locals who've figured out what the reviews already confirm: the weekday lunch here beats most restaurants in town on all three counts that actually matter, food quality, price, and service. The staff knows your name by the second visit. The portions are honest. Nothing on the menu is pretentious.

Beyond the lunch counter, Lodge 484 is an active community organization rooted in the tradition of the Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks, one of America's oldest fraternal groups. Members gather here for events, fellowship, and the kind of low-key good time that's harder to find than it used to be. With a 4.7-star rating across 60 reviews, the place earns its reputation one plate at a time.

What We Offer

The public lunch is the headline act, served weekdays to anyone who walks through the door. Expect hearty, home-style plates at prices that feel almost too reasonable in 2024. The menu rotates, but the quality stays consistent, which is why so many people make it a standing weekly habit rather than a one-time curiosity.

For members, Lodge 484 offers a full calendar of social events, charitable programs, and community initiatives that reflect the Elks' national mission. The clubhouse is available for gatherings, and the bar area provides a comfortable spot to unwind after work without the noise or expense of a typical restaurant bar.

Takeout is available for the lunch service, making it easy to grab a quality meal even on a busy workday. If you've been driving past this building on South Main for years without stopping in, the only question worth asking is why you waited this long.

Gallery

Take a look at our space and what we have to offer

“The club is near downtown New Castle, Indiana. They serve lunch open to the public on the weekdays. The staff is friendly and the food is good.”

— John Hall

What Our Guests Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear it from our members & guests

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 years ago
"I often order takeout lunch because the food, prices, and service can't be beat. I'm not a member and didn't know until a short while ago they're open to everyone for lunch."
— Leah Driver
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
6 years ago
"The club is near downtown New Castle, Indiana. They serve lunch open to the public on the weekdays. The staff is friendly and the food is good."
— John Hall
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 years ago
"It's a great place to go and hang out where everyone is just there to have a good time, plus the food is really good too."
— Ken Ripberger
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 years ago
"Excellent food and reasonable prices. It's a "hidden" gem in downtown New Castle!"
— Mary Lines
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
3 years ago
"Good solid food menu. Good people. Join the Elks and come on down."
— Zachary Burcham

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to be an Elks member to eat lunch here?

No. The lunch service at Elks Lodge 484 is open to the general public on weekdays. Anyone can walk in and order without a membership or sponsorship.

What days and hours is the public lunch served?

Lunch is served on weekdays. Hours can vary, so it's a good idea to check the lodge's website at elks484.com or call ahead to confirm the current schedule before your first visit.

Can I order takeout instead of dining in?

Yes. Takeout is available during the lunch service, which is one reason so many local workers make it a regular stop. Just call ahead if you want your order ready to go.

Where exactly is Elks Lodge 484 located?

The lodge is at 309 S Main St in New Castle, Indiana 47362, close to downtown and easy to find along the main corridor through the city.

How do I become a member of the Elks Lodge?

Membership in the Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks is open to U.S. citizens who believe in God and are of good moral character. Visit elks484.com or stop in during a public lunch to ask a member about the application process.

Does the lodge host events or rent the space for private gatherings?

Yes. Lodge 484 hosts member events, charitable programs, and community activities throughout the year. Contact the lodge directly through elks484.com to ask about event availability and details.

What kind of food is on the lunch menu?

The menu features hearty, home-style American dishes at very reasonable prices. The specific offerings rotate, but reviewers consistently praise the quality and portion sizes. It's comfort food done right.

The Order · Since 1868

Community. Friendship. Charity.

Every Elks lodge belongs to one of America's oldest and largest fraternal orders. Through the Elks National Foundation, the Order has given more than $481 million to college scholarships, veterans, and neighbors in need.

Join the Elks
A Proud Heritage

The Elks gave America
Flag Day.

Long before it was a national observance, the Order set aside June 14th to honor the flag. Patriotism has always been one of our cardinal principles, and every lodge meeting still closes the same way it has for over a century.

“To our absent members.” — the Eleven O’Clock Toast

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts

More places nearby

Other spots near here, whatever their type. Tap one to open its page.

Supplier ★ 4.2 (2,137)
Rural King
0.7 mi127 S Memorial Dr, New Castle
Restaurant ★ 4.6 (321)
Ink & Ale Brewhouse
steps away239 S 14th St, New Castle
American Restaurant ★ 4.5 (450)
Culver’s
0.7 mi605 S Memorial Dr, New Castle
Bowling Alley ★ 4.6 (487)
Rose City Bowl
0.6 mi550 S Memorial Dr, New Castle
Restaurant ★ 4.2 (1,661)
Applebee's Grill + Bar
0.6 mi109 S Memorial Dr, New Castle
Restaurant ★ 4.4 (1,289)
Weenee World
0.8 mi601 N Memorial Dr, New Castle
Hardware Store ★ 4.5 (262)
Ace Hardware
0.7 mi441 S Memorial Dr, New Castle
Fast Food Restaurant ★ 3.8 (1,264)
Wendy's
0.6 mi524 S Memorial Dr, New Castle

Contact Elks Lodge

Send a note and Elks Lodge will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you
Community · Friendship · Charity

Who are the Elks?

The Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks is one of America's oldest and largest fraternal orders, founded in 1868. Every lodge is a home for fellowship, service, and patriotism in its own hometown.

$481M+given through the Elks National Foundation for scholarships, veterans, and community programs.

What the Order does

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.